top of page
Beautiful Cake in Central PA

Customer Reviews

See what customers throughout Central Pennsylvania are saying about Mae’s Makin’s custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and desserts.

IMG_0595.heic
IMG_0125.heic
IMG_9616.heic

Kelly Davis

Mae did cupcakes for our gender reveal- they were simply amazing.
They looked beautiful and tasted great. All of our guests commented on how great they were.
She also did a cake for my nieces birthday. She went above all expectations and it turned out amazing too.
Would definitely recommend, and have already.

March 10, 2021

Kayla Fye

She did an amazing job with my husbands 30th birthday cake! It was also very delicious! Will definitely be getting another one!!!

May 8, 2022

Caylie Taylor

We ordered multiple flavors of cupcakes for an event and all of them were fantastic! Everyone commented all day how much they loved the cupcakes and some family members ate more cupcakes than food I think. Mae was super easy to work with and we’ll be ordering more in the future!

July 17, 2022

Brenda Tormey Huber

Everyone loved Easton’s birthday cake. It was delicious!! Will definitely order from Mae again.

July 17, 2022

Courtney Chantele

Mae made my son's cookies for his birthday, and they were absolutely AMAZING! everyone loved them! we ordered again

February 19, 2023

Courtney Watson

Cookies are cheaper than Crumbl cookies and taste way better! The chocolate brownie cupcake was delicious.

July 5, 2023

Megan Norris

These are the best cupcakes we've had in awhile! Well worth the 30-40 minute drive!

October 21, 2023

Paige Pistner

We absolutely loved our son’s 1st birthday smash cake!! Not only did we love it AND he love it, but the frosting didn’t stain his skin and wiped right off in water afterwards!! thank you so much for your work!

January 6, 2024

Mandee Baker Yebernetsky

everyone loved the cupcakes and kept saying how delicious they were. very easy to work with and responds quickly. very friendly owner. customer for life here

March 24, 2024

Jessica Smith

Mae is my sister and she's always loved baking. Her desserts are absolutely delicious and am always referring people to her. Her skill set just keeps getting better and better, along with her ability to envision new flavor combinations and designs.

July 7, 2024

Kelly Drum

Ordered cupcakes and cookies, and they not only looked amazing, but they were also delicious! Definitely worth the drive to Philipsburg!

July 20, 2025

bottom of page